104 KELIGION
and drawing a few long, almost hysterical breaths, would imme-
diately proceed to foretell the future. He talked to many people
present, one by one. When he was through with one case, he
would stop for a while, as if recollecting himself, and then, after
several deep-drawn sighs, would pass on to the next applicant.' ^
C. Incantation shamans [ewganva-t'irgin, ' producing of incan-
tations '), who carry on the more complicated practices of sha-
manism.
Incantations, together with spells, form the greater part of
Chukchee magic. The incantations may be of a benevolent or
malevolent character. Hence there are two types of shamans in
this class :
1. 'Well-minded' {ten-cimnulln), who \Ay tlieir art in order to
help sufferers.
2. 'Mischievous' {l;urg-cncnUit, or Icunich-enenilit, literally 'mock-
ing shamans '), who are bent on doing harm to people.
Good shamans have a red shamanistic coat and bad shamans
a black one. The same colours are used by the Yukaghir shamans.
The majority of shamans, however, coml)ine in themselves the
gifts of all these categories and in the name of 'spirits' perform
various tricks, foretell the futui'e, and pronounce incantations.
The Neo-Siberians.
TJte YaJcut. Troshchanski - suggests that the division of
shamans into black and white is the most essential division
among all Sil)erian tribes, though many travellers speak of
shamans in a general way as if there were only one kind. It
would seem, however, that Troshchanski overlooks the distinction
between the religious conceptions of the Palaeo-Siberians and
those of the Neo-Siberians. They live under different environ-
mental conditions ; and, besides, the Neo-Siberians have un-
doubtedly been to i-ome extent influenced by contact with the
higher Asiatic religions.
It is among the Neo-Siberians that magico-religious dualism
appears more distinctl)'. Again, within the class of Neo Siberians
themselves differences are found. Among the Yakut "' the black
shamans predominate, the Avliite hardly existing ; while among
' Op. cit., p. 431.
- Troshchanski, The Evolution of the Black Faith, 1902, p. iii.
=* Op. cit., p. 110.
TYPES OF SHAMANS 105
the Voty.ik tlio white are ahuost the only shaiiKins now to be
foinul, as the cult of the bright god has almost entirely displaced
that of the black.
The Yakut white shamans are called a'iif-ohOHi. They take part
in the spring festivals, marriage ceremonies, fertilization rites, and
the curing of diseases, in cases where li(t has not yet been taken
away from the patient.^
We read in a certain tale that at one wedding there were
piesent nine aiij-oitina (white men-shamans) and eight aqi-udagana
(white women-shamans).^ White shamans also ask, in cases of
the sterility of women, the maghan sylgiilalcli to descend to earth
and make the woman fertile. At the autumn fishing, in former
times, they lighted torches made of wood cut from a tree struck
by lightning, purged the waters of all uncleanness, and asked the
ichchi (spirit-owner) of the lake for a benefit. This, he considers,
was certainly done by white shamans, if only for the reason that
the ceremony was held in the daytime.^ But, on page 105 of the
same work, Troshchanski writes : ' Only the spring festivals were
called liiii-iisiialh ; the autumn festivals were known as ahassij-
i/si/alh.' Hence the ceremony of fertilization of the lake must have
l>een performed l)y black shamans, ahas>:i/-oiuna, in spite of the
fact that this ceremony was held in the daytime.
As to the characters of the two kinds of shamans, Gorokhoff
says that he knew personally several ai/j-ohiua, who were very
good people indeed, quiet, delicate, and really honest, while the
abassy-oiiina were good for nothing.^ But Troshchanski says that
the ' black shaman ' among the Y^'akut is only professionally
* black ', that his attitude has no specially evil character, and that
he helps men no less than the white shaman does. He is not
necessarily bad, though he deals with evil powers, and he occupies
among the Yakut a higher position than among other Neo-
Siberians.
Black shamans offer sacrifices to ahass/jlar and shamanize to
maintain their prestige. They foretell the future, call up spirits,
wander into spirit-land, and give accounts of their journeys
thither. '5
At the present day there are among the Yakut special story-
tellers and also special sorcerers {apfah-kisi).
> Op. cit., p. 149.
* Kbudiakoft", Verkhoyansk Antholofjy, p. 88. ' Troshchanski, ibid.
* Gorokhoft; YuvungUolan, E. S. S. 1. R. G. S., 1887, p. 56.
* Troshchanski, op. cit., p. 152.
o 2
11»G RELIGION
According to the degree of esteem in which they are held by
the people, Sieroszowski ' classifies Yakut shamans as follows :
(1) The Great Shaman — nlahan-oiitn.
(2) The Middling Shaman — orto-o'lun.
(

The Little Shaman — Iccnniki-o'iun.
A ' great shaman ' has the amCuijiat from Tlu-To'icn himself.
A shaman of middling power also possesses (imari>/af, but not of
so high a quality or to so great an extent as the former.
A ' little shaman ' does not possess amiigi/af. He is not, in fact,
really a shaman, but a person in some way abnormal, neurotic, or
original, who can cure trifling illnesses, interpret dreams, and
frighten away small devils only.
With regard to the classification of shamans into ' white ' and
' black ', Troshchanski puts forward the hypothesis that these two
classes of shamans originated and developed independently :
' One might imagine that the class of white shamans came into
existence first, and that it derived from the class of heads of
families and clans. The custom of the choice of one leader
(shaman) for common ceremonies or sacrifices may have helped in
this evolution of the white shaman from the heads of families.
The wisest and most respected member of the community would
probably have the best chance of being chosen, as he could please
not only the people but also the spirits.'^
The same persons might then have been chosen repeatedly, and
presently a class of white shamans might arise for the communal
cults and sacrifices. In the meantime the head of the family
could still keep his priestly power in his own home, until the
professional shaman took his place, as we see at the present day
among certain tri])es, e.g. the Yakut.-'
Why should we regard the head of the family as the prototype
of the white shaman ? We shall find in Troshchanski's book no
more satisfactory reply to this question than is contained in the
following short passage :
' I think we are right in saying that the heads of the familj',
or the chosen priests, in their practice and i)rayers do not address
themselves to the evil spirits, which in Yakut are called abassylar;
hence it is here that we find the origin of white shamans.*^
If we follow Troshchanski, we must draw the conclusion that
' Sieroszewski, op. cit., p. 628. - Troshchanski, op. cit., p. 120.
3 Op. cit., p. 124. " Op. cit., p. 113.
TYPES OF SHAMANS 197
among the Neo-Siberians. e.g. the Buryat and the Yakut, the
white shamans form a quite distinct chiss, although we see that
on certain occasions the head of the family may take the place of
the white shaman :
^Taihjan is a communal sacrifice in which the whole family or
clan takes part. This ceremony is designed to show humilitj- :
the BurN'at call it the ''asking ceremony". The performer of
taihjan may be the shaman, or the whole group of family heads
without the assistance of a shaman.'^
Among the Palaeo-Siberians there is no class of white shamans,
and the family cult is in the hands of the father, assisted by the
mother, the participation of professional shamans being often
prohibited. Among the Gilyak the assistance of shamans at
sacrificial feasts, e.g. the bear-ceremonial, is even forbidden. Is
this because there is no white shaman among these people ? Or
is it an indication that, after all, family and professional
shamanism have developed separately?
Among the Yakut, from the observation of whom Troshchanski
formed his hypothesis, the white shaman may be a woman, in
cases where the woman stands as family head.-
Now as to the black shamans, they were originally women,
says Troshchanski, and he draws attention to the following
linguistic and sociological jiarticulars wliich are made to act as
evidence in support of his hypothesis.
What is the essential meaning of the word shaman? In
Sanskrit ^ram = to be tired, to become weary; ha))iana = work,
religious mendicant. In the Pali language the word samana has
the same meaning. These two latter words have been adopted by
the Buddhists as names for their priests."' But, according to
Banzaroff, the word sltanian originated in northern Asia : sainan
is, a Manchu word, meaning ' one who is excited, moved, raised ' ;
mmmun (pronounced shaman) and hamman in Tungus have the
^ Agai^itoff and KhangalofF, Materials for the Study of Shamanism in
Siberia, E. S. S. I. R. G. S., p. 36.
* How this may occur, in the patriarchal Yakut family, Troshchanski
explains as follows : ' Each wife of a polygynous Yakut lived separately
with her children and relations and cattle ; during the frequent absences
of her husband she was actually the head of the family, and performed
family ceremonials. Several such ye-usa (matriarchal famiUes) formed
one aga-usa (imtriarchal family) ' (p. 116).
^ I am indebted for this information to Mr. M. de Z. Wickremasinghe,
Lecturer in Tamil and Telugu in the University of Oxford.
198 RELIGION
same ineaiiing. Sdnidamhi is Manchu : 'I shamanize ', i.e. *I call
the spirits tlaiK-iny before the charm.' ^
From the above we see that the essential characteristic of
a shaman is a liability to nervous ecstasy and trances. Women
are more prone to emotional excitement than men: among the
Yakut most of the women suffer from mcncriJc (a nervous disease,
one type of the so-called 'Arctic hysteria ').'-
Thus Troshchanski. But the only conclusion — if any — that he
could draw from this would be tliat women are ]>y nature more
disposed to shamanizing than men. And why should this make
her the original llacJc shaman ? Only one piece of evidence is
adduced to connect women with ' black ' shamanizing, and that is
taken from Kamchadal life, not from that of the Yakut, upon
which chiefly he grounds his hypothesis. Among the most
primitive Kamchadal, Avhere there were only women (or loel-
clmeh) shamans, these practised only black shamanism, sum-
moning evil spirits.^
As to the linguistic evidence :
Among the Mongols, Buryat, Yakut, Altaians, Torgout, Kidan,
Kirgis, there is one general term for a woman-shaman, which has
a slightly different form in each tribe : utugun, udagan, udayhan,
nhalchan, iitygan, vtiugioi, idiian (duana) ; whereas the word for
man-shaman is different in each of these tribes.
In Yakut he is called ohm ; in Mongol, huge ; Buryat, huge and
ho ; Tungus, samman and hamman ; Tartar, Jcam ; Altaian, Imn and
gam ; Kirgis, halsa {hasl'g) ; Samoyed, tadihcij.
From the above Troshchanski concludes that during the migra-
tion of the Neo-Siberians they had only women-shamans, called
by a similar general name ; and that the men-shamans appeared
later, when these people scattered, settling in lands distant from
one another, so that the term for man-shaman originated in-
dependently in each tribe."^
Of course this linguistic evidence concerns only the Xeo- and
not the Palaeo-Siberians.
Troshchanski gives us further the following religio-social evi-
dence, drawn exclusively from the Yakut, in support of his
^ Zakliaroff, CoDrplctc Mcnichii-Iiui^siaii Didioiuoy, 1875, p. 568.
^ Troshchanski, op. cit., p. 119.
^ Krasheniiiuikoft', Description of the Country of Kanichatlrt, pp.
81-2.
?* Troshchanski, op. cit., p. 118.
TYPES OF SHAMANS 199
hypothesis of the evolution of the 'black* man-shainan from the
* black ' woman-shaman :
(a) On the Yakut shaman's apron there are sewn two iron
circles, representing breasts.^
{h) The manshaman dresses his hair like a woman, on the two
sides of the head, and braids it ; during a performance he lets the
hair fall down.-
((•) Both women and shamans are forbidden to lie on the right
side of a horse-skin in the ifioia.'''
{d) The man-shaman wears the shaman's costume only on very
important occasions ; in ordinal y circumstances he wears a girl's
dress made of the skin of a foal.^
(e) During the first three days after a confinement, when Ayisit,
the deity of fecundity, is supposed to be near the M-oman who is
lying-in, access to the house where she is confined is forbidden to
men, but not to shamans.''
How the female black shaman was displaced by the male black
shaman Troshchanski explains as follows, again using exclusively
Y'akut evidence :
The smith who made the ornaments for the female shaman's
garment acquired some sliamanistic power. He was in contact
with iron, which was of magical importance, and power came to
him througli this contact. (The smiths were, like the shamans,
' black ' and ' white ', but among the Y^'akut one hears more of
'black' smiths than of 'white'.) Thus the similarity between
the vocation of a shaman and that of a smith becomes close,
especially when the calling of smith descends through many
generations in the same family. Smiths come to be considered as
the elder brothers of shamans, and then the differences between
them finally disappear, the smith becoming a shaman.
The v.'oman, then, since she could not be a smith, had even-
tually to give up her place to the man.
In modern times, as there are no longer any ' magical smiths ',
new shamanistic garments cannot be made.''
' Krasheninnikoft', op. cit., pp. 81-2. ^ Ibid.
^ Troshchanski, op. cit., p. 123. * Ibid. ^ Ibid.
" Troshchanski. op. cit.. p. 125. It will be interesting to quote here
what Sieroszewski says about the vocation of the smith: 'Those who
approach most nearly to the shamans in their office, and are partially
related to them, are the smiths. "The smith and the shaman are of one
nest", says a proverb of the Kolyma district. The smiths also can cure,
advise, and foretell the future, but their knowledge does not possess
200 RELIGION
This hypothesis of women being the first Ijlack shamans is,
however, not borne out by the evidence. Even if we allow that
the above quotations, especially that containing the linguistic
evidence, tend to show that women were shamans before men. it
does not follow that they were the first hkicJc shamans. There is
not enough evidence in Troshchanski's book to support his
hypothesis of two separate origins and developments for black
and white shamans.
On the other hand, the evolution which Troshchanski ascribes
to black shamans might be ascriljed to professional shamanism, if
we reject Jochelson's and Bogoras's view that professional de-
veloped out of family shamanism.
The Altaians. Wierbicki ^ says that among the Altaians, besides
the shaman, called lam, there are also (i) rijnchi, ' who, during
attacks accompanied by pain, can foretell the future ' ; (ii) telgochi,
or 'guessers'; (iii) yarinchl, or those who can divine by means of
the blade-bone ; (iv) Jcoll-lcurcchi, who divine from the hand ; (v)
yadachi, who control the weather by means of a stone, yada-tash,
which is found in narrow mountain defiles, where winds )dow
continually. To obtain these stones a yadachi must swear away
all his possessions. Hence he is poor, lonely, and usually a
widower.
Tlie Buryat. Among the Buryat, according to Shashkoff,-
shamans are divided into {«) hereditary shamans and {b) shamans
of the first generation. Another division is into («) real, (fc) false
a magical character ; they arc simply clever people, who know much,
and who i^ossess " peculiar fingers ". The profession of smith is gene-
rally hei-editary, •especially in the north. It is in the ninth generation
that a [hereditary] smith first acquires certain supernatural qualities,
and the more ancient his ancestry, the more marked are these qualities.
The spirits are generally afraid of iron hoops and of the noise made by
the blowing of the smith's bellows. In the Kolyma district the shaman
would not shamanize until I [Sieroszewski] removed my case of instru-
ments ; and even then his bad luck in shamanizing was explained by
him as due to the fact that, as he said, " the spirits are afraid of smiths
[in this case Sieroszewski], and that is why they do not appear at my
call." Only a smith of the ninth generation can, without harm to him-
self, hammer out the iron embellishments of the shamanistic dress, the
iron for the drum, or make ihndgyat. If the smith who makes a shaman-
istic ornament has not a sufficient number of ancestors, if the noise of
hammering and the glare of the fire does not surround him on all sides,
then birds with crooked claws and beaks will tear his heart in pieces.
Respectable hereditary smiths have tools possessed of" spirits " [ichchilah)
which can give out sounds by themselves.' (Sieroszewski, op. cit., p. 632.)
^ The yatired of the Altai, pp. 44-6.
2 Shashkoff, Shamanism iii Siberia, W. S. S. I. R. G. S., p. 82.
TYPES OF SHAMANS 201
shamans. Again tliere are {a) white {sagan-ho) and {h) black
{Juirahi-hd).
The \Yhite and bhick shamans, the Buryat say, fight with each
other, hurling axes at one another from distances of hundreds of
miles. The white shaman serves the West tcngerl and West
Ihafs, and has charge of the ceremonies held at birth, marriage,
&c. He wears a white coat and rides a white horse. A famous
white shaman was Barlak of the Balagansk district, at whose
grave liis descendants still go to w'orship.
The black shaman serves the tengcri and lihats of the East.
These shamans are said to have power to bring illness and death
upon men. They are not liked, but much feared, by the people,
who sometimes kill black shamans, to such a point does this
dislike develop.^ The grave of a black shaman is usually shaded
)jy aspens, and the body is fastened to the earth by a stake taken
from this tree.
According to Agapitoff and Kangaloff, there are also a few
shamans who serve both good and bad spirits at the same time.
The Samoycd. Lepekhin - says that the Samoyed sliamans are
not divided into distinct classes, black and white, as among the
Buryat, but serve both for good and bad ends, as occasion arises.
The Lapps likewise make no strict distinction between good
shamans and bad. Some of the Lapp no//da (shamans) are known
as ' Big ', and others as ' Little ', noyda.
The VotyaJc. The whole Votyak hierarchy arose from the white
shamans. The chief of the shamans is the tuno. At the present
day the tuno^ is the chief upholder of the old religion.
As the soul of a tuno is ' educated ' by the Creator, he is
without doubt a white shaman. Besides the tnno, there are
priests, chosen either by himself or by the people under his
advice. ' In most cases the profession and knowledge of a tuno
descend from father to son, althougli any person who has the
opportunity of acquiring the knowledge necessary to a tuno can
become one.'^